Stocks / AFL vs SIGI

AFL vs SIGI: Which Stock Is the Better Buy?

AFLAC Incorporated and Selective Insurance Group, Inc. side by side — fundamentals from SEC filings, refreshed nightly. Sector: Financial Services.

On the fundamentals, SIGI grows revenue faster (12.8% vs -5.0%); AFL earns a higher net margin (21.2% vs 8.6%); SIGI has the stronger return on equity (12.7% vs 12.4%). On the filings, SIGI carries fewer potential red flags (0 vs 1). Full numbers below — the stronger figure on each row is in green.

AI verdict — AFL vs SIGI, read from the filings

The stronger business, the cheaper stock, and the risks — synthesised from both companies’ SEC filings, every figure computed not guessed. Not investment advice.

 AFLAC Incorporated (AFL)Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI)
Market cap$5.5B
Revenue (latest FY)$17.16B$5.34B
Net income (latest FY)$3.65B$457.20M
Revenue growth (5y CAGR)-5.0%12.8%
Net margin21.2%8.6%
Return on equity12.4%12.7%
P/E ratio14.612.5
Dividend yield1.9%1.8%
Profitable years (of last 10)1010
Positive free cash flowYes

Verify the comparison

Use the filing period and source shown by each tool before treating two figures as comparable.

Compare with another company:

See the full AFL vs SIGI breakdown

Both companies across 19 years of income statement, balance sheet and cash flow — with ratios, health checks and Ask, the SEC-grounded research assistant. Free, no account needed.

Open AFL's full financials →   Open SIGI's full financials →

More comparisons

Frequently asked questions

Which is bigger, AFL or SIGI?

Market capitalization data is not available for both companies.

Which grows faster, AFL or SIGI?

Over the last five fiscal years, Selective Insurance Group, Inc. grew revenue faster — 12.8%/yr versus -5.0%/yr, computed from SEC-filed statements.

Where does this data come from?

All figures are computed from official SEC filings (10-K), refreshed nightly. This is a data comparison, not investment advice.

Keep exploring

AFL fundamentals → · SIGI fundamentals → · All 1,500+ companies → · Free screener →